Inspired by a comment on my look back at the top moves of the offseason, I was inspired to go back and look at some of the transaction of the 2002 offseason. This isnt a comprehensive list, by any means, but an analysis of some of the more interesting moves that offseason.
The Colorado Rockies traded Juan Pierre, Mike Hampton, and cash to the Florida Marlins for Charles Johnson, Preston Wilson, Vic Darensbourg, and Pablo Ozuna
After 3 seasons in Colorado, in which he stole 100 bases, the Rockies shipped him in order to get rid of Hampton. Pierre had his 2nd best year(his best year came in 2004) playing centerfield for the World Series winning Marlins. He and Luis Castillo formed a very fast, very pesky top of the order, and Pierre actually finished 10th in the MVP voting. After 3 seasons in Florida, he was traded to the Cubs for Sergio Mitre, Renyel Pinto, and Ricky Nolasco. Hampton was traded two days later to the Braves for Tim Spooneybarger and a minor leaguer, along with some cash.
Charles Johnson was a shell of his former All-Star self at that point, and hit .230(albeit with 20 homers) at the age of 31. He was finished after 2005. Preston Wilson had his best year in 2003, collecting his only all-star appearance by leading the league in RBI's, and hitting 36 homers. He too went downhill pretty quickly, and played just 25 games for the Cardinals in 2007, and has never cracked 30 homers or 100 RBI's since. Darensbourg and Ozuna were blips on the radar for Colorado.
The Cleveland Indians traded Einar Diaz and Ryan Drese to the Texas Rangers for Travis Hafner and Aaron Myette.
Hoo boy, did this one pan out for the Indians. The complaint here isnt that the Rangers traded Hafner(though they probably shouldnt have), its that the didnt get enough. To understand this trade, you have to understand why Texas considered trading him.
At the time, Texas had Rafael Palmerio at first, who was coming off a 43 homer season, and Mark Teixeria coming up. They clearly didn’t have enough places to play these guys, though with Palmerio a free agent after 2003, it might have behooved them to stock up on depth.
Hafner meanwhile, was coming of 4 straight 20 homer seasons in the minors, slugging over .500 in all those seasons. His lowest OBP in that period was .373, and he peaked at .450.
Myette was a 24 year old right who had struggled in his time in the majors, but had posted good ERA’s and WHIP’s in the minors.
Diaz was a 29 year old catcher who posted a .542 OPS in 102 games in the majors. He had never posted a league average OPS to that point, and his best days in the minors had come back in 1998, when he posted a slightly above league average OPS of .782, though oddly below the team OPS. The Rangers were about to lose Pudge to free agency, so they were in need of a catcher.
Drese won 10 games in his rookie season of 2002, posting an ERA over 6 in the process. Drese had posted decent ERA and WHIP numbers in the minors.
At this point, you’d have to say the Indians got the player with the most potential, while Drese and Myette almost cancelled each other out, leaving Diaz. I think, at the time, not considering the years of hindsight here, that the Indians got an edge here.
You know how the rest turns out. Hafner became a near MVP candidate, Drese and Diaz spent a combined 3+ seasons in Texas(with Diaz playing just 2003 for the Rangers). Drese pitched well in 2004, winning 14 games and having a better than average ERA. Diaz was traded before the 2004 season in a deal for Chris Young, so he at least helped there. Myette was done in the majors after 2004.
The St. Louis Cardinals signed Chris Carpenter as a free agent
Carpenter signed with the Cardinals after being released earlier in the offseason by the Blue Jays. Carpenter missed most of 2002, and underwent surgery to repair a torn labrum. It could be argued that Carpenter, a former first round pick, had been an average pitcher for the Jays, with a win loss record of 49-50, with a 4.83 ERA. However, he was just 27 at the time
The Cards took a chance on Carpenter, and monitored his health. He didn’t pitch at all in 2003, and came back to win 15 games and the NL Comeback Player of the Year award. He followed that up with a 21 win Cy Young year in 2005 , and won 15 games in 2006 for the WS Champs. Carpenter barely pitched in 2007, and underwent TJ surgery. Props though to the Cards front office, for taking a chance. They didn’t have to give up anything but money, paying him just $300,000 to miss all of 2003.
The Minnesota Twins released David Ortiz.
The Boston Red Sox signed David Ortiz as a free agent.
Think the Twins want this one back. Ortiz went on to greater things with the Sox, and has finished in the top 5 in MVP voting every year with the Sox, without winning one. Ortiz has hit 208 homers as their DH, and has been incredible in the postseason for them, hitting 11 homers in 160 postseason at bats with Boston.
There were rumors of a personality clash in Minnesota, but nothing has ever been substantiated
.
The Atlanta Braves traded Kevin Millwood to the Philadelphia Phillies for Johnny Estrada.
Millwood was about to get a big raise via arbitration(he wound up 9+ million in 2003), and the Braves had committed too much money by acquiring Russ Ortiz, and the the surprise of Greg Maddux accepting arbitration. The Braves made a last minute move, and dealt the 18 game winner to division rival Philadelphia, getting catcher Johnny Estrada in the process. Javy Lopez went on to have a big 2003, and Estrada was barely seen in a Braves uniform.
Millwood posted below average ERA in his two years for the Phillies, and wound up signing with Cleveland after the 2005 season. The Phillies netted Adrian Cardenas with their compensation pick, and Cadenas has impressed in his two minor league seasons, posting a .784 OPS, and was ranked as the Phillies #2 prospect by Baseball America.
Estrada won the Silver Slugger award in 2004, hitting .314. It was his only year posting an OPS over league average, and he was traded after 2005 for Lance Cormier and Oscar Villareal.
The Chicago White Sox traded Rocky Biddle, Orlando Hernandez, Jeff Liefer, and cash to the Montreal Expos for Bartolo Colon and Jorge Nunez
Colon went 15-13 for a 2nd place White Sox crew. After 2003, he signed with the Angels, and went on to win a Cy Young. The ChiSox netted Tyler Lumsden for their troubles.
El Duque never pitched for the White Sox, as he had arthroscopic surgery and missed all of 2003. He signed with the Yankees in the offseason. Biddle provided 2 seasons of what could be considered relief, and Liefer was waived during the 2003 season. In short, a whole lot of nothing.